Reducing Turn Around Time (TAT) seems to be on a perpetual hit list among writers of journals, case studies, and contracts. Indeed, what a nobler topic to champion? Speedier TAT’s result in greater availability of the asset being turned around. For aircraft this means more Revenue Kilometer Miles; for engines and components, greater availability of spares, or a reduction in spares inventory- music to the ears of CFO’s. What irks me however, and compels me to pen this blog, is that most of what has been written seems to exhibit a myopic focus on a single contributor to TAT: the supplier, and further, to lack frank honesty and comprehensiveness. If the goal is greater availability of the asset, the enlightened discussion must transcend this single contributor. In this blog I hope to present a frank picture of the entire Rotable TAT Cycle logistics chain; the holistic view.
Many contracts with MRO providers will contain a TAT performance provision. These contracts likely define what TAT means, when the TAT ‘clock’ starts and stops, and the penalties for the lowly supplier not meeting the stated TAT’s. Let’s broaden our scope. Every operator, including Airlines, the Military, and General Aviation (collectively ‘operator’) has their system to control the logistics aspect of the operation deemed necessary to support the maintenance of the fleet. This system typically controls the allocation of the stations with the spares, the number of spares, minimum stocking levels, parts in the ‘pipeline’ etc. The holistic discussion of the Rotable TAT Cycle falls into four distinct divisions:
TIME AT THE OPERATOR DURING THE REMOVAL PROCESS: CREATING THE ‘HOLE’
Let’s put the hole in holistic. When should the whole TAT clock start? That is the fundamental segway into this holistic discussion. Simplistically, it starts at the operator. A Mechanic/Technician/Engineer (herein Technician) will draw the part from stock. At that point a ‘hole’ is recognized by the operator’s logistic system; that a spare is no longer available. Thumb on stopwatch please.
o How long did it take between the time the inspection’s write-up was created (which identified that the part needed
replacement), and when the unserviceable part was removed?
o If the part was not in stock, how long did it take between the time the inspection’s write-up was created (which
identified that the part needed replacement), and when the backorder was created?
o How long did it take for the part to issue once ordered? Did it have to be delivered from another warehouse or
location; a pick ticket issued and closed, the computer transactions, etc.?
o How long did it take between the time the unserviceable part was removed at the aircraft, and then properly turned in
to supply?
o What was the elapsed time since supply took-in the unserviceable part until it was placed for pickup?
FREIGHT TIME TO AND FROM THE SUPPLIER:
One time a colleague misspelled freight as fright, and of course it was not corrected by spellcheck. He became the person credited as putting the fright in freight. And indeed, fright is a component of freight, primarily due to its costs. Costs and delivery times vary widely from Sterling service to ground delivery. Let’s look at some of the variables
TIME AT THE SUPPLIER:
As mentioned earlier, this segment of the rotable TAT cycle is nearly universally the single topic of discussion in published literature, so I’ll only dwell on a few of the more interesting variables.
TIME AT THE OPERATOR WHILE BEING RETURNED TO STOCK: FILLING THE HOLE
The delivery truck roll-up door opens and the boxed, now serviceable window is unloaded. Is that it? Is the hole now filled? Not so fast. Let’s look at some of the variables.
THE ’WHOLE’ IN HOLISTIC
Any research literature or informative article on TAT that does not reflect this holistic view does its audience a disservice, and helps perpetuate the view that the sole contributor in the Rotable TAT Cycle is the supplier (Industrial Engineers are heard to be clapping in the background). The bottom line is that in the Rotable Cycle, there is room for improvement at every level, and only by a frank and open discussion can improvements be made.
PS: I looked up “holistic” in the dictionary before I started to use it, and discovered there is nothing ‘Holy’ about it. Shouldn’t it be ‘wholistic’? Alas, my major was not in English…
When I hear popular culture terms, I tend to borrow the lingo so I don’t seem remote and out of touch. A term I’ve heard bandied-about is ‘TMI’, or Too Much Information. ‘TMI’ might be uttered by you following a conversation with an acquaintance who shared information that was socially awkward, over-the-top, or just plain overwhelming. But this is the age of information, which reportedly is the new gold standard. If so, when is information too much?
Having information or data does not necessarily make you smart; any more than having a big collection of books in your home or office library makes you well-read. Data becomes gold when we put it to work for us. And so it is with the big data being generated by today’s aircraft.
So Royboy, TMI? What TMI? Consider the following:
“An A320 generates information from about 20,000 data sources, Airbus says, compared to 200,000 for an A380 and more than 400,000 for an A350.” 1
How about:
“Take an average jet engine from a commercial airliner, which can be equipped with over 5,000 individual sensors, as an example. According to SAP business software, these engines can generate around 20 terabytes of data per hour.”2
And there you have it; that is big data! Let’s develop this; there are many dots to connect. Here are the topics to be discussed:
SOURCES OF THE DATA:
In order to gain a proper perspective on the evolution and typical sources of aircraft data, I encourage you to read a previous blog: “AUTONOMIC LOGISTICS”, here’s the link:
http://www.aviationsuppliers.org/index.asp?bid=222&BlogEntryID=76&FormID=300
IMMEDIATE USES:
Various OEMs are going to call these uses by any number of names, but generically we can refer to the following:
· Aircraft/Engine/Helicopter Health Monitoring: Simply, the data being generated is telling us something has failed.
· Predictive Maintenance: Based on trending data, something, if left unaddressed, may fail in the near future.
· Analytics: This emerging field is software based and designed to sift through the reams of data and perform the required analysis. The desired result is that, in the parlance of the CIA and NSA, you get ‘actionable intelligence’.
COLLATERAL USES:
Here are the existing and developing uses of all this data:
http://www.aviationsuppliers.org/CHRONIC-OR-ROGUE-PARTS
WHO WILL MINE THE DATA?
Right now the big airframers offer fee-based programs for operators. The engine OEMs are very strong in similar programs, and perhaps history will write that they indeed pioneered the evolving techniques. Following the airframe and engine OEMs are the OEMs of the systems and LRUs, particularly since the aforementioned issues of reliability and warranty are in play; they are highly motivated to mine the data for those reasons, and to perform what I call ‘Targeted Analytics’.
How about MROs? Many airlines outsource a significant portion of their maintenance programs to MROs. This ranges from line maintenance, to component maintenance, to full airframe and engine overhauls. Will the airline give big data access to the MRO? Will the airline accept the MRO fees for acting on ‘actionable intelligence’ derived from management and analysis of the data?
POSSIBLE EFFECTS UPON THE AFTERMARKET:
Currently, other than the aforementioned OEM use of the data, there does not appear to be direct aftermarket use of the data; indeed its use is still evolving. In the near future however, there will be a trickle-down effect upon the accuracy of the following:
ALIS is going to be the harbinger and standard-setting system by which such big data integrates into logistics and aftermarket support systems. What works and doesn’t work is going to have a major trickle-down effect on nascent civilian programs.
FUTURE ENHANCEMENTS:
o Assist operators and manufacturers to attain and maintain higher reliability through trend monitoring
o Evaluate if certain problem areas are unique to an operator or observable throughout the industry
o Monitor which modification has a better payback by comparing removal and failure rates of operators who have incorporated various service bulletins/modifications
o Determine utilization rates through aircraft flight hours, flight lengths and number of landing cycles
o Assist operators and manufacturers in determining the effectiveness of aircraft maintenance programs
There is no doubt that the new big data will progressively become the source of such information sharing systems.
BROAD ACCEPTANCE HAS BEEN SLOW
Finally, it seems that broad acceptance and implementation of the benefits of aircraft big data has been slower than anticipated1. This is curious since OEMs continue to market their data-driven support systems as producing maintenance savings of approximately 10-15%. How about:
“…with 10 times return on investment for aviation companies and a potential 70 to 75 percent reduction in airplane breakdowns, there is a clear case for automated predictive maintenance in the aviation industry.”2
Sounds convincing, but reluctance may be driven by the following:
We’ll see…
Over ‘n out
Roy ‘Royboy” Resto
AimSolutionsConsulting.com
1 Surely, but Slowly; Aviation Week & Space Technology; April 11-24, 2016; Page 36
2 http://www.aviationpros.com/article/12236185/man-versus-machine-aviations-predictive-maintenance-challenge
It’s time once again to dive into the murky world of undefined terms with my professor’s hat properly donned. By undefined I mean the that the term is not clearly ensconced in regulations or standards.
AS REMOVED:
With the rise in popularity of aircraft and engines being disassembled to harvest parts for a supply-chain starved market, the use of the term ‘As Removed’ has come into effect, and this is really the genesis of the term. The moment the part is removed from its next higher assembly, its condition is deemed As Removed or AR.
AR Infers that the part is being represented as an unserviceable part whose airworthiness must be reestablished before it can be installed on an aircraft. Discussion:
AS IS:
Implies the part is being sold in whatever condition or state it’s in. In the aviation industry this usually means there are trace and/or documentation issues and/or condition issues. Note that it is not contrary to any regulations to buy or sell parts in As-Is condition as long as the known circumstances are clearly represented. The installer has ultimate responsibility to determine the part’s airworthiness and suitability for installation. As stated in the As Removed paragraph, the term As Is appears to have fallen into disuse in favor of the more palatable AR term. If so, Royboy thinks this is unfortunate since in some cases it appears the seller is trying to cloak something…there, I said it and I meant it!
SERVICEABLE:
The term has come to have two meanings:
FACTORY NEW:
This term does not have any regulatory definition. Its de-facto use in the industry, however, implies that the part was recently obtained directly from the OEM. Discussion:
Some of this comes from a document I make available for sale titled “Trace And Airworthiness Training Manual” (a shameless plug).
Roy Resto
www.AIMSolutionsConsulting.com
Scenario: You are a distributor, and you have an MMR (Multi Mode Receiver) in your Quarantine Cage because the MRO- Maintenance Repair & Overhaul shop returned the part to you as BER- Beyond Economical Repair due to an unrepairable power supply. There is a customer who is looking for a cover whose part number is the cover for the MMR in the Q Cage. You simply remove the 10 screws to disassemble the cover from the MMR assembly, and voila, you have an AR- As Removed condition part and you’re a hero to your customer because this part was not to be found on the market.
Certainly, this is a simple example, but the concepts we’ll go over in this article can be applied to this small assembly (the MMR) or to major assemblies such as Landing Gears, APUs, and Air Cycle Machines. This brings to mind many details we’ll cover in this article including the following:
BACKGROUND:
USM or Used Serviceable Material is increasingly popular as an alternative to factory new parts whose prices have soared, and lead times extended. Besides those well-known supply chain issues there are in some cases a challenged aftermarket environment due to certain OEM behaviors as explained in this blog article:
https://www.aviationsuppliers.org/AIRLINE-MX-COSTS-WILL-GO-UP
An increasingly popular source of USM parts is from aircraft and engines which have been disassembled.
Before we go any further, we need to point out that the ‘S’ in USM means Serviceable (Inspected, Tested, Repaired, Overhauled). Nearly all parts disassembled from a NHA- Next Higher Assembly are at that moment in AR- As Removed condition. That AR part will have to be sent to a Repair Station/AMO- Approved Maintenance Organisation which will reestablish the part’s airworthiness before it can be installed on an aircraft. I only mention this because the USM moniker is bandied about for a broad range of parts in the aftermarket including these AR unserviceable parts, so its ok to continue to use USM if this is kept in mind.
Do I need to be Certificated by an AA- Aviation Authority? As long as you are not declaring any of the disassembled parts as airworthy, then the answer is no. This is neatly articulated in Jason Dickstein’s blog article:
https://aviationsuppliers.wpcomstaging.com/2014/08/28/no-aircraft-disassembly-is-not-a-maintenance-activity-under-the-faa-regulations/
AFRA Intro. For firms whose core business is disassembly of entire aircraft, engines, or any subcomponents, there is likely an affiliation with AFRA, Aircraft Fleet Recycling Association.
https://afraassociation.org/
AFRA has established disassembly and recycling standards whereby compliant firms can be accredited for Disassembly, Demolition, and Recycling; see the Directory tab at the noted website. With a certainty this article is not suggesting that any of your limited disassembly activates as a distributor be accredited by AFRA, but you should be made aware of their standards and activities in case you want to step up your game. It is interesting to note the synergies between the ASA and AFRA which are quite natural considering the overlapping activities of each other’s members. For example, many AFRA accredited firms are ASA-100 and vice versa. You’ll also notice that the ASA and AFRA annual conferences have been held concurrently now for many years.
FORMS AND PROCEDURES TO CONSIDER.
Procedures in your manual. The ASA-100 paragraph 1.A.1) states:
If you’re selling parts from your disassembly operation under your accredited name and enjoying the business benefits of your ASA-100 accreditation therein, then there is the expectation that your Quality Manual will describe your disassembly operations (exception: you are also AFRA accredited and disassembly procedures are described in the AFRA manual). Consider some of the items presented here for inclusion. Consider placing this in your manual:
Tags: Perhaps one of the most important documents to implement which facilitates the sale of the part and establishes the trace trail (more on that later), is the use of the Removal or Identification Tag. Here is a blank sample and a filled-in example:
Currently, use of such a tag is dominant in the industry and is sometimes supplemented by, or replaced by a Manifest of removed parts, but the current best practice is the simple tag. It should be affixed immediately upon removal. This is just a sample, and variations of it are common.
Do I need a certificated Technician to perform the disassembly? There are certainly advantages to using a Certificated Aircraft Technician to perform your disassembly operations. Generally, they are familiar with Technical Manuals, tools, and proper handling of aircraft parts. Some firms also feel that having a Technician exercise their credential on the removal tag, for example “A&P Joe Smith” is added value or adds credibility to the process. To be certain, however, this is not required. Royboy’s recommendation is then to use someone with attention-to-details, and who is mechanically inclined.
Who can issue an ‘Inspected’ 8130-3 or equivalent for removed parts from a disassembly of an aircraft? If you are a Repair Station or Approved Maintenance Organisation, and you have a written procedure in your manual to do so, you’re the one who can issue an Inspected tag (8130-3 or equivalent). I have written procedures accepted for this process, and these should always have a document number, for example WI-1501. Here’s a quick summary of the logic. An aircraft arrives at your hangar for disassembly. For it to have flown there it must have been Airworthy, and the Airworthy Certificate carried on board. Except for any open write-ups in the logbook, you can reasonably assume that the aircraft (and its parts and components) are airworthy. If there are any open write-ups, they will be found in the logbook with its ATA chapter noted. Let’s say you want to start to remove all the radios. You look in the logbook and there are no ATA Chapter 23 write-ups. Next you go to the AMM- Aircraft Maintenance Manual and find in chapter 23 where it typically requires a visual inspection of the system during operational checks or troubleshooting. You perform the visual check and find nothing untoward. You remove the radio, cap it, and the resulting 8130-3 says Inspected as its condition. I highly recommend that the remarks block transparently and plainly state the circumstances involved, for example, “Removed from MSN 12345”. Of course, the remarks must also contain a reference to the AMM and cite your written procedure. For example, “Visually Inspected per AMM 23-15-44 paragraph 23-14, and (Company Name) Procedure WI-1501.”
Regarding this process, some customers will accept such parts, and some won’t. I was once told by an airline person wagging their loaded finger at me that this could not possibly be allowed! I countered by saying, ‘then how is it that you’re allowed to do it?” What! For more info read this background article titled “Cannibalizing, Robbing, and Swapping Aircraft Parts” at this link:
https://www.aviationsuppliers.org/Cannibalizing-Robbing-and-Swapping-Aircraft-Parts
The following is a simple and generalized flowchart regarding tagging options for a disassembly I have presented in the past at conferences. Apologies if it seems small for the posting.
Removal Log. If you have a complete assembly of any kind and you start to harvest parts from it, Royboy highly recommends that you have a method to track the parts removed from this Next Higher Assembly. Why? The reason is that if for any reason you are now presented with a PO (Purchase Order) for the entire assembly, you’ll have to restore or provide the parts removed in order to sell it as a complete assembly. If you have a Removal Log entry for every part that was removed, you now have a simple listing to facilitate the process. The Removal Log would always stay with assembly.
I distinctly recall my airline days whereby we had spare engines at a few major bases, and those engines were always tempting targets to harvest parts which were not in stock. The written procedure included posting a Removal Log so anyone would instantly know what parts were missing and on order.
Tooling, Capping, Bagging, Packaging. In addition to a wide assortment of tools it is recommended that you also have a wide assortment of caps and plugs for electrical, pneumatic, fuel, oil, and hydraulic connections upon disassembly. This must include a reasonable assortment of ESD caps and bags for such parts. Depending on the size and type of part being disassembled, consider hoists, drip pans (for parts with oil, fuel, or hydraulic fluids which will leak), or stands made for major assemblies such as engines and APUs, see below.
Trace Considerations/representations. If you have heard me speak or read many of my articles, you’ll have taken notice of my repeated use of the word ‘transparency’, and so it is with parts that have been disassembled from a NHA. Our customers continue to require clear and transparent trace as stated on their T&Cs- Terms and Conditions on their Purchase Orders. For the example given for the MMR cover, providing the removal tag (or copy) is important. Next is what is the trace for the MMR? Unless you’re selling the part in AR condition, then of course your documentation package would include the Airworthiness Release Certificate from whomever you used to perform the Overhaul, Repair, or Inspected/Tested.
Records: As with any activity occurring in your distributorship, and as required by the ASA-100 and nearly all Quality Standards and Aviation Regulations, keep precise records which are reasonably accessible upon request.
Royboy’s Parting Counsel:
This article was written without the use of any AI apps or programs.
Roy ‘Royboy’ Resto
www.AimSolutionsConsulting.com
POV: Forever that acronym will be etched in my memory as Privately Owned Vehicle of government expense report fame, but today it has gained social media popularity as Point of View. Today I’ll stick to the latter.
Depending on your POV, Artificial Intelligence, herein AI, is either a panacea fueling aerospace growth, or is a harbinger of the apocalypse. I’ll stick to the former.
As many of you know if you have been following my posts for any length of time, I fancy myself an unofficial historian for all things of significance contributing to aerospace and its aftermarket, and as it is, AI is shaping up to be worthy of such recognition.
In this article we’ll review the following:
WHAT IS AI:
There is a myriad of definitions for AI, but I found a simple basis from an aerospace source, NASA1.
Artificial intelligence refers to computer systems that can perform complex tasks normally done by human-reasoning, decision making, creating, etc.
AI CONCEPTS DU JOUR
AI APPLICATIONS IN THE SUPPLY CHAIN AFTERMARKET:
https://www.aviationsuppliers.org/AIRCRAFT-BIG-DATA-ANALYTICS-AND-THE-AFTERMARKET
CURRENT AI USES BY AIRLINES:
In addition to Predictive Maintenance, the airlines also are implementing these programs.
WHAT TO LOOK FOR IN THE NEAR FUTURE:
It’s no secret that AI has some teething pains in the way of limitations. According to Ahmet Erdemir, “AI methods are currently limited by the ability of classical computers to process complex data. Quantum computing can potentially enhance AI’s capabilities by removing the limitations of data size, complexity, and speed of problem solving.”7. This will supercharge AI.
Dilbert:
Dare I say it? This article was written without the use of AI generated content.
https://www.linkedin.com/in/royresto/
1 https://www.nasa.gov/what-is-artificial-intelligence/
2 The State of AI; Aviation Week & Space Technology; January 13-26, 2025; Page 40.
3 Generative AI ‘Super Analyst’ May Change How Airlines Set Prices; Aviation Week & Space Technology; January 13-26, 2025; Page 46.
4 MRO Industry Expands Potential AI Use Cases; Aviation Week & Space Technology; January 13-26, 2025; Page 51.
5 https://news.mit.edu/2023/explained-generative-ai-1109
6 https://www.simpleque.com/how-to-incorporate-ai-tools-into-your-quality-management-system/
7 https://www.lerner.ccf.org/news/article/?title=+How+quantum+computing+will+affect+artificial+intelligence+applications+in+healthcare+&id=79c89a1fcb93c39e8321c3313ded4b84005e9d44